Last week a business owner told me her social media “wasn’t working.”
I asked what she meant. She said her follower count had barely moved in three months and her last reel got 200 views.
Then I asked if more people had come in lately. She paused. “Actually, yeah. We’ve had a few new people mention seeing us on Instagram.”
Her social media was working. She just didn’t know how to read it.
Here’s the thing nobody tells local business owners: the metrics that feel important almost never are.
Follower, views, likes… they feel like a scoreboard & approval ratings. When those numbers are low or flat, it feels like proof that social media doesn’t work for you or your business.
But none of those numbers tell you what you actually need to know, which is whether the right people in your area are starting to recognize you.
For an e-commerce brand, views and reach make sense as primary metrics. They’re selling to strangers. And the whole world. The more eyes, the better. But your business doesn’t work that way. You’re not trying to reach a million people. You’re trying to become the obvious choice for the 5,000 people who actually live near you. You’re trying to prove yourself over the 4 other options within your mile radius.
Recognition doesn’t show up in your analytics. It shows up when someone walks in and says “I want to try this thing I saw on Instagram” It shows up when a regular brings a friend who already knows your face. It shows up when people don’t Google you anymore, they just come in.
That’s what you’re building. (And it’s almost invisible in your analytics dashboard.)
So what do you actually track?
I tell my clients to shift from vanity metrics to signal metrics. Here’s the difference:
Vanity metrics (feel important, don’t tell you much):
- Follower count
- Views on individual posts
- Likes
Signal metrics (tell you if the strategy is working):
- Are you getting DMs from people in your area?
- Are new customers mentioning social media when they come in?
- Is your profile visits number increasing week over week?
- Are people saving or sharing your posts, not just scrolling past?
- When you post about something specific, do you see it come up in conversations?
None of these are perfect. But they’re closer to the truth than a follower number that barely moved this month.
Get free insider info from me every other week 💌
The other shift that matters: stop measuring posts and start measuring patterns.
One post getting 300 views doesn’t mean anything. But 12 weeks of consistent, strategic content that’s reaching new people, building familiarity, giving them a reason to show up: that compounds. That’s what changes a business.
Local recognition is slow to build and hard to measure. That’s also why most people quit before it kicks in. They look at the dashboard, see a flat line, and assume the strategy isn’t working. Meanwhile, they’re three months away from becoming the place everyone thinks of first.
The businesses that win at local social media aren’t the ones posting the most. They’re the ones who kept going long enough for recognition to compound.
If you’re in that middle place right now: posting consistently, not sure if it’s doing anything – I want you to ask yourself a different question than “are my numbers up?”
Ask: Are the right people starting to recognize me?
That’s what will compound. Don’t forget that people need to see a product 7-14 times before deciding to buy. But once that starts to compound, the numbers take care of themselves.
— Haley
P.S. If you want a clear system for what to post, when to post it, and how to know it’s working: that’s what the Content Collective is built for. $97/month, no guesswork. Learn more here!!!
Leave a Reply